In both its vulgar and heavenly versions, however, the agape differs from eros in kind, not degree. In the first volume of agape and eros he looks at the two fundamental motifs. It considers some major themes on their own terms and whether those terms can bear the fullness of the gospel vision to which nygren would be faithful, in an effort to bring forth something of the power and the limits of this classic in christian ethics. Agape theology for the love of wisdom and the wisdom of. Anders nygren agape and erostransfer ro12mar783538 free ebook download as pdf file. Click download or read online button to get eros in agape book now. In the second volume of the book nygren studies the history of the conflict between the two motifs.
Reconciling classical eudaemonism with christian love robertc. Loriginale svedese apparve nel 1930 prima parte e nel 1936 seconda parte. Pdf agape and eros, by anders nygren carl l bankston. Eros in agape download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi.
While nygren finds no connection between vulgar eros and agape, heavenly eros is agapes chief rival. Nygren therefore argues that agape is the only truly christian kind of love, and that eros turns us away from god. Anders nygrenanders nygren 18901978 was a leading representative of the socalled lundensian school of theology. Anders nygren agape and erostransfer ro12mar783538 scribd. Expressions of love in sacramental marriage joann heaneyhunter, ph. God does not love that which is already in itself worthy of love, but on the contrary, that which in itself has no worth. Dewdney no one can read bishop nygren s great work agape and eros without gratitude and much delight. Download citation anders nygrens agape and eros this article analyzes the character of christian love in agape and eros. We all need to learn to handle all these areas of love for a balanced christian life. Anders nygrens midtwentieth century work, agape and eros, is monumentally important for the contemporary dialogue between science and theologies of love. Nygren anders agape and eros free ebook download as pdf file. It was written in 1930 by the swedish theologian anders nygren, who held a professorship at the university of lund and also.
Agape and eros thought paper by dale martin gospel study group. The new testament only uses the words phileo and agape. Eros and agape ascending love and descending love can never be separated. William werpehowski, anders nygren, agape and eros. If you have access to a journal via a society or association membership, please browse to your society journal, select an article to view, and follow the instructions in this box. Nygren rightly asserts the study of agape to be one of the most central and yet most neglected in the theological field. Agape and eros by anders nygren examines the concept of love within christianity and its development throughout history. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Are eros and agape fundamentally different kinds of love. Anders nygrens agape and eros is the most famous representative of this project aiming at the purity of christian agape. Complete summary of anders nygren s agape and eros.
It is important for us to understand the place of these four types of love in the christian life. Even when it is attributed to god, eros is patterned on. Jocelyn marked it as toread oct 19, marissa marked it as toread may, lewiss reply to anders afape. Anders theodor samuel nygren 15 november 1890, gothenburg 20 october 1978, lund was a swedish lutheran theologian.
His agape theories were and are preached regularly from christian pulpits. For nygren, agape is the properly christian understanding of love, as is evident from new testament texts such as the synoptic gospels, pauls theology of the cross, and the identification of god and agape in the first letter of john. For nygren, agape is the properly christian understanding of love, as is evident from new. He was professor of systematic theology at lund university from 1924 and was elected bishop of lund in 1948 emeritus 1958. He outlines a mingling of new testament agape, hellenisms eros and jewish law. Nygrens work contains a trenchant statement of the fundamental incompatibility of the classical eudaemonism of socrates, plato and aristotle the object of eros. This classic documents how the agape motif, the core of the christian message, was obscured by p.
This article analyzes the character of christian love in agape and eros. Eros och agape is a treatise written by the swedish protestant. This study is the most comprehensive account to date of modern treatments of the love commandment. Vacek criticizes common understandings of agape, eros, and philia, examining the arguments of aquinas, nygren, outka, rahner, scheler, and other theologians and philosophers. The study demonstrates that lewiss concept of spiritual longing, which he calls joy, is relevant to the nygren debate and serves as a potent variant for nygrens eros. An important figure in the ecumenical movement, he served as president of the lutheran world federation. When examining nygrens hypotheses pertaining to love, gene outka concludes, whatever the reader may think of agape and eros, one may justifiably regard this work as the beginning of the. He was professor at the university of lund, sweden, then bishop of lund. He is best known for his twovolume work agape and eros first published as eros and agape in swedish 19301936. Gene outka examines the literature onagapefrom nygrensagape and erosin 1930.
Both roman catholic and protestant writings are considered, including those of darcy, niebuhr, ramsey, tillich, and above all, karl barth. Nygrens famous book, agape and eros, influenced christian education in churches and universities around the world. Anders nygrens agape and eros, first published in the 1930s, was a landmark treatment of the radical distinction between eros and agape realizing that the christian bible makes large use of agape and little use of eros, nygren seeks to understand why this is the case. Some luther scholars have argued that luthers central 1 john milbank, the future of love. The central theme of agape and eros is the comparison of christianitys and. Eros and agape is a treatise in the fields of philosophy and religion. There cannot actually be any doubt, he writes, that eros and agape belongoriginally to two entirely separate spir. Alexander rated it it was amazing feb 20, also see hall, anders nygren that agape and eros should have no organic relation to one another in actual human life seems at best counterintuitive, and shifting our focus from the problem of selflove to the problem of selfdenial helps us.
He defines love as an emotional, affirmative participation in the beloveds real and ideal goodness, and he extends this definition to the love between god and self. The particularities have garnered extensive scholarly response. To him, the problem of a distorted agape arose within the early church of the 2nd century. Agape in christianity and eros in hellenism mainly platonism. This classic documents how the agape motif, the core of the christian message, was obscured by platos eros motif in the dark ages and how agape was recovered by the lutheran reformation. Eros in mysterypiety is the vulgar eros of the senseworld. This is one of those monumental works of which only a very few are produced in any generation and which help to clarify and mould the thinking of men everywhere. Swedish theologian anders nygren commented that numerous books were written on the doctrinal details of christianity, but few tackled the idea at its heart love. The more the two, in their different aspects, find a proper unity in the one reality of love, the more the true nature of love in general is realized.
Anders nygrens midtwentieth century work, agape and eros. Dewdney no one can read bishop nygrens great work agape and eros without gratitude and much delight. This longstanding assumption is shown to be in need of greater nuance. In his insistence on identifying eros with acquisitive selflove while there are passages in the platonic dialogues that possibly justify this reading, nygren seems to have overlooked those that do not, he misses the side of eros that contributes to the creative nature of agape. Nygren was here summarizing luthers position as he understood it, but with obvious approval, for he had identified luther as the one who destroyed the medieval caritas synthesis rooted in augustine, and restored agape to its place as true. Levinas between agape and eros university of alberta. David bourget western ontario david chalmers anu, nyu area editors. It is argued that agape generally includes a selfconcerned but. Access to society journal content varies across our titles. Read download eros agape and philia pdf pdf download.
1155 1271 787 888 1558 955 926 33 1190 921 1217 249 805 346 991 315 618 633 1343 639 1465 348 809 925 976 414 21 273 898 129 1054 176 43 617 274 500 415 881